Winner: Super Paper Mario
"Super Paper Mario was a game with a mission. A mission with a purpose. A purpose with a friend. A friend with cancer. The friend died, and then Super Paper Mario was sad." -Orie House, RPG Land ramblings on Super Paper Mario.

Runner up: Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn
"It's all about impressive, challenging gameplay in the Fire Emblem series, and [insert Fire Emblem title] uses just that to work its way to the top." -Heath Hindman, every time a Fire Emblem game wins an RPG Land award

Honorable mention: Pokémon Battle Revolution
"Let me show you them." -Internet.

Don't stop now, fatty: